Authors recommend diet stability and palatability assays
Production of live food for the rearing of larval marine fish constitutes a major operational cost and bottleneck in commercial marine fish culture. The variability and poor nutritional quality of live food are major concerns during production.
Research has been directed toward developing compound microdiets to replace live food to ameliorate this problem. Although extensive research has been performed during the last 25 years, studies to determine specific nutritional requirements such as amino acid and vitamin requirements are scarce and the formulation of adequate diets is still elusive.
Formulating complete diets
Larval performance on compound microdiets alone is, in general, inferior to that of live food. One question that arises from previous studies is whether the technological processes utilized to manufacture microdiets is adequate to emulate live food acceptability and digestibility. The authors recommend that diet research incorporate comprehensive evaluations that include diet stability and palatability assays, which are not usually performed for marine larvae diets.
Much work has been devoted to biological evaluation, such as bioassays that last longer than six weeks, but the only parameters evaluated in most feeding trials are growth and survival. The authors propose that several key parameters be investigated during the manufacturing of practical compound microdiets for first-feeding marine fish larvae.
The ideal compositions of compound microdiets are species-dependent, but common guidelines can be followed based on previous research (Table 1). The authors have modified the approach suggested by Yufera and coauthors in 2000, which included a three-step process: diet design, biological evaluation and digestibility evaluation. The following research strategy is proposed.
- Selection of ingredients.Use fresh by-products from marine organism processing plants (although they represent potential vectors for disease), fishmeal, and a protein hydrolyzate to provide intact proteins, peptides, and free amino acids, as well as highly unsaturated fatty acids (Table 2).
- Selection of binder/technology. Use a mixture of polysaccharides and proteins that are highly digestible. The application of combing fluidized bed dryer and microbound flake technology is suggested.
- Stability evaluation. Test the leaching rate of soluble protein, peptides, and/or amino acids. The authors evaluated soluble protein using a modified Bradford technique.
- Acceptability evaluation. Study ingestion rates with and without gentle aeration during five hours using larvae not fed for 24 hours. The authors evaluated animals at 16 days posthatch.
- In vitro digestibility. Compute using the following equation.
Relative protein digestibility = (Δ Abs.280CMD / Δ Abs.280Caseine) x 100
Medina-Reyna, Recommended nutrient levels for compound microdiets, Table 1
|Nutrient||g/100 g diet|
|g/100 g diet
|Free amino acids||10|
for marine fish larvae.
Medina-Reyna, Experimental diet formulation, Table 2
|Ingredient||g/100 g diet|
|Skipjack orbital oil||14.8|
|Cod liver oil||4.9|
|Whey protein concentrate||0.6|
|Proximate composition (%)|
Experimental diet tested
In a study that applied the above stategy, the authors selected several ingredients available locally and combined them with fishmeal to provide a nutritionally balanced diet for marine fish larvae. Although the 67 percent protein content seems high, previous experience has shown lower ingestion rates with microdiets. The level was chosen to satisfy requirements using a nutrient-dense approach.
A binder mixture enhanced the mechanical properties of the dough during the flaking process, but pieces of fishmeal were not hydrated satisfactorily or homogenized as fresh ingredients. The combination of these factors resulted in a diet that was easy to prepare.
Although the ingredients were finely ground to 10-20 μ to produce a microdiet of 250 μ, the soluble protein-leaching rate was a satisfactory 0.5 percent per hour. Leaching of other nutrients should be evaluated to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of diet stability. The relative protein digestibility of 80.4 percent seemed adequate, but should be confirmed using larval digestive enzymes and ultimately correlated with in vivo assays.
Acceptability tests with California halibut larvae were initially performed in tanks without aeration. The compound microdiet tended to sink quickly in less than 30 minutes. When gentle aeration was provided, ingestion rates significantly increased, with even higher rates in the presence of microalgae. The behavior of the diet in the water column must be evaluated and optimized prior to biological evaluation trials.
(Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in the August 2004 print edition of the Global Aquaculture Advocate.)
Now that you've finished reading the article...
… we hope you’ll consider supporting our mission to document the evolution of the global aquaculture industry and share our vast network of contributors’ expansive knowledge every week.
By becoming a Global Aquaculture Alliance member, you’re ensuring that all of the pre-competitive work we do through member benefits, resources and events can continue. Individual membership costs just $50 a year. This year, GAA individual and corporate members receive complimentary access to the virtual GOAL conference in October. Join now.