News features and technical articles about the evolution of aquaculture, one of the world’s fastest growing industries.

Feed trays or broadcasting?

Dr. Carlos A. Ching Dr. Chalor Limsuwan

Broadcast method reduces organic matter in shrimp ponds

feed trays
This aerial view of an Ecuadorian shrimp farm using the “all feed in trays” method shows organic matter accumulation on pond bottoms in tray areas. Photo by Sebastian Arias.

Three Latin American shrimp farms visited by one of the authors applied all feed via 20 feed trays/ha to shrimp stocked at 20/m² or more in earthen ponds. Depressions were observed in these ponds bottoms after harvest, and the average amount of feed for each tray was over 1 kg in the last month of each production cycle.

Measurements of organic matter concentrations on pond bottoms showed significant differences between feeding and non-feeding areas (Table 1). Values for feed tray areas were above the recommended 3 percent concentration.

Ching, Average soil organic matter, Table 1

CountryOrganic Matter Feed Tray AreasOrganic Matter Outside Tray Areas
Brazil5.35%2.50%
Ecuador3.50%1.76%
Peru4.23%2.05%
Table 1. Average soil organic matter concentrations at three shrimp farms.

To address this, the farms decided to level their pond bottoms and changed their feeding methods to broadcast the feed, using only 3 feed trays/ha for feed samples to evaluate consumption. Since then, soil quality improved and shrimp survival increased.

Intensification

Many shrimp farms using earthen ponds in Latin America have applied the “all feed in trays” method for many years. With low stocking densities and proper pond bottom preparation, high concentrations of organic matter in the soil were avoided. However, in recent years, stocking densities increased at many Latin American farms, and the amount of feed applied in each tray rose to more than 1 kg/tray.

When some of the added feed went underneath the trays, thousands of shrimp dug under the trays and caused depressions. In these depressions, the concentrations of organic matter from feed, feces and exuviae increased above the 3 percent recommended value in every cycle of production and led to bacterial disease outbreaks. Thus, many farms are changing their feeding method to broadcasting.

feed trays
When too much feed is applied in trays, shrimp activity under the trays forms depressions that accumulate organic matter.

Broadcast feeding

Due to the large amount of feed they use, most farms in Asia broadcast all their feed with only small feed samples on feed trays. Latin America is following suit as its farm densities rise.

The method for broadcasting feed used by most of the shrimp farms in the world consists of broadcasting 94 to 97 percent of the feed dose, leaving 3 to 6 percent of the dose to be divided as samples on feed trays. The criteria used for this method depend on the season and size of the pond.

The number of feed trays is defined by the area of the pond (Table 2). In small ponds with intensive culture, more feed trays per hectare are used than in large ponds over 2 ha used for extensive or semi-intensive culture.

Ching, Recommended number of feed tray, Table 2

Pond Area (ha)Trays/ha
Below 26-10
2-54-5
5-102-3
Over 101-2
Table 2. Recommended number of feed tray based on field results at Latin American farms.

Some farms not willing to change their “all feed in trays” approach are overcoming the problem of using too much feed by increasing the number of daily feed doses and/or installing more feed trays, but these changes increase labor costs and logistics.

(Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in the September/October 2012 print edition of the Global Aquaculture Advocate.)