News features and technical articles about the evolution of aquaculture, one of the world’s fastest growing industries.

Oxygen demand of aquaculture feed

Claude E. Boyd, Ph.D.

High-quality feeds, feed monitoring, water quality management should be high priorities

Oxygen demand
Although the oxygen demand caused by feed is strongly influenced by feed-conversion efficiency, a value of 1.25 kg oxygen per kg feed is reasonable for general use.

The fate of feed applied to aquaculture systems is illustrated in Fig. 1. A portion of the feed is either not eaten or expelled as feces. This part is decomposed by bacteria that consume oxygen and excrete ammonia nitrogen in the process.

Feed nutrients absorbed by the culture species are used in respiration, excreted as ammonia nitrogen and other metabolites, or converted to biomass and removed from the culture system at harvest. Generally, 8 to 12 percent of the organic carbon and 20 to 30 percent of the nitrogen contained in feed are removed in biomass at harvest.

Dissolved oxygen removed from the water by respiration of culture animals, microbial decomposition of uneaten feed and feces, and oxidation of ammonia nitrogen by nitrifying bacteria represent the oxygen demand of the feed. Much of the oxygen demand is expressed in the pond during the culture period.

However, some of the oxygen demand is deferred until later because some of the organic carbon from feeding waste is stored in sediment organic matter. A portion of the demand is also externalized by discharge into natural water bodies through overflow or water exchange, and when ponds are drained for harvest.

feed
Fig. 1: The fate of feed applied to aquaculture ponds.

Oxygen demand of feed

Nutrients from feed stimulate phytoplankton photosynthesis that produces dissolved oxygen and organic matter in ponds. The amount of oxygen produced in photosynthesis is sufficient to oxidize the organic carbon produced in the process, and the oxygen demand of feed should not include the organic matter produced by photosynthesis.

The oxidation of organic carbon requires 2.67 units of molecular oxygen per unit organic carbon regardless of whether oxidation is by bacteria or the culture species. The oxidation of ammonia nitrogen to nitrate nitrogen by nitrifying bacteria requires 4.57 units of molecular oxygen per unit of nitrogen.

Shrimp ponds

To illustrate the calculation of the oxygen demand of feed (Fig. 2), assume that the feed-conversion efficiency (FCE) in a shrimp pond is 0.556, feed-conversion ratio (FCR) is 1.8, feed contains 6 percent nitrogen and 45 percent carbon, and shrimp contain 2.75 percent nitrogen and 11 percent carbon. One kilogram of the feed will produce 0.556 kg shrimp. This amount of feed contains 0.06 kg nitrogen and 0.45 kg carbon, and the shrimp produced with it contain 0.015 kg nitrogen and 0.0612 kg carbon.

Subtracting the carbon and nitrogen in 0.556 kg shrimp from that in 1 kg feed gives a waste load of 0.045 kg nitrogen and 0.389 kg carbon. The oxygen demand of the feed is (0.0045 kg nitrogen × 4.57) + (0.389 kg carbon × 2.67) = 1.245 kg oxygen per kg feed. These computations can be arranged into the equation in Fig. 2.

feed oxygen
Fig. 2: Calculation of feed oxygen demand.

The oxygen demand of feed varies with FCE as illustrated in Table 1 using feed and shrimp composition data from the example above. Notice that FCE does not make a large difference in the oxygen demand per kilogram of feed. Moreover, there is not a large variation in nitrogen and carbon percentages in feed and shrimp.

Therefore, a value of 1.25 kg oxygen per kg feed would seem to be reasonable for general use. Feed-conversion efficiencies, feed composition and body composition do not vary tremendously for most warmwater culture species. Thus, an oxygen demand of 1.25 kg oxygen per kg feed also can be used for most types of warm-water aquaculture.

The oxygen demand caused by feed added to the culture system, however, is strongly influenced by FCE as also illustrated in Table 1. Improving the FCE from 0.417 to 0.625, which lowers the FCR from 2.4 to 1.6, reduces the feed oxygen demand by 1.18 kg oxygen per kg shrimp – a reduction of 37.8 percent.

Boyd, Feed efficiency and oxygen demand, Table 1

Feed-Conversion EfficiencyFeed-Conversion RatioOxygen Demand of Feed (kg oxygen/
kg feed)
Oxygen Demand of Feed to Produce 1 kg Shrimp (kg oxygen/kg shrimp)
0.6251.61.2141.94
0.5661.81.2452.24
0.5002.01.2662.53
0.4552.21.2852.83
0.4172.41.3013.12
Table 1. Feed efficiency and oxygen demand of feed to produce 1 kg of shrimp.

Such a large reduction in oxygen demand would improve water quality in ponds. It also would lessen the oxygen demand of effluents discharged from ponds. Equally important, it takes 0.8 kg less feed to produce 1 kg shrimp at an FCR of 1.6 than at 2.4 – a considerable economic advantage. Thus, implementation of measures such as using high-quality feeds, adopting feeding practices to assure that most applied feed is eaten, and practicing good water quality management that can reduce FCR should be given high priority by producers.

Much of the feed oxygen demand is exerted in ponds. In flowing water systems, uneaten feed and feces often are partially removed by sedimentation before final effluent discharge. Therefore, the feed oxygen demand is not a substitute for the biological oxygen demand of effluent from ponds and flow-through systems.

In cage and net pen culture, all carbon and nitrogen not removed in fish biomass enters the ecosystems containing the cages or net pens. The oxygen demand exerted on the ecosystem can be estimated as follows:

 

Tilapia, salmon cages

A tilapia cage culture operation in a lake that produces 10,000 metric tons (MT) annually at an FCR of 1.7 will use 17,000 MT feed per year. Assuming the feed oxygen demand is about 1.25 kg oxygen per kg, the oxygen demand imposed upon the ecosystem would be 21,250 MT per year.

Much lower FCRs are typically achieved in salmon culture than in tilapia culture. Approximate calculations suggest that the oxygen demand of salmon feed in a system with an FCR of 1.1 also would be about 1.25 kg oxygen per kg feed. Because of the lower FCR, salmon cage culture would result in a smaller oxygen demand upon the surrounding ecosystem than caused by production of an equal quantity of tilapia in cages.

(Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in the November/December 2009 print edition of the Global Aquaculture Advocate.)


GAA’s GOAL 2020 conference may be over ...

… but the content lives on. For GAA individual and corporate members, all 10 program sessions – a total of 15 hours of content – are accessible on-demand in the GOAL 2020 conference platform and GAA member toolkit, as are PDFs of GOAL 2020 presentations.

Not a GAA member? Join us.

Support GAA and Become a Member