News features and technical articles about the evolution of aquaculture, one of the world’s fastest growing industries.

Self-regulating PHA technology offers denitrification for marine aquaculture systems

James M. Ebeling, Ph.D. Pradyot Deshpande Douglas G. Drennan II Patrick G. Simms

Polyhydroxyalkanotes are a family of biodegradable biopolymers produced from sugar fermentation

denitrification
Nitrogen gas bubbles rise through the floating PHA pellets in the experimental denitrification bioreactor units.

Nitrate, the end-product of nitrification, has historically not been of major concern in recirculating systems due to its low toxicity to freshwater organisms. However, with the inherently high degree of water reuse in marine recirculating aquaculture systems, nitrate reduction becomes critical due to the compound’s toxicity to marine organisms from its effects on the animals’ osmoregulatory abilities. These effects can be manifested in the inhibition of reproductive cycles, poor egg development, delayed hatching times, reduced growth rates, and higher mortalities. 

Additionally, nitrate is very stable in the natural environment and can be a source of pollution in waters that receive aquaculture effluent. Nitrates can cause eutrophication and algal blooms, and resulting high dissolved-oxygen consumption as the algae die off. 

The United States Environmental Protection Agency has limited the nitrate and nitrite concentrations in potable water to 10 and 1 mg per liter, respectively, and placed their control on the priority list. While denitrification can be expensive, at some point in time, it will be mandatory for facilities with limited water supplies or stringent discharge requirements.

Denitrification

Denitrification is the process in which nitrate is oxidized to nitrogen gas and removed from water. This process can be optimally mediated by denitrifying bacteria under specific conditions, such as low redox potential, low oxygen levels, availability of organic carbon and nitrate sources, pH of 7.0 to 8.5, and a temperature range of 25 to 32 degrees-C. 

Denitrification achieved by adding water-soluble carbon sources such as methanol, ethanol, or acetic acid is a traditional tool used by the waste treatment industry to reduce nitrogen pollution. However, sophisticated and costly computer control systems are often required to properly regulate the carbon dosage. 

In the absence of nitrate in an anaerobic environment, excess carbon can reduce the redox potentials, promoting the reduction of sulfates and production of toxic sulfides. Denitrification methods also require multiple treatment components, further increasing the overall cost. 

Alternative carbon source

In 2006, Aquaculture Systems Technologies, LLC (AST) received a Phase I U.S. Department of Agriculture Small Business Innovation Research Program (SBIR) project to investigate the potential for using polyhydroxyalkanotes (PHAs), a family of biodegradable biopolymers produced from sugar fermentation, as an alternative carbon source for denitrification in recirculating aquaculture systems. 

The biodegradation of polyhydroxyalkanotes in the presence of nutrients releases organic carbon, which makes them an ideal substrate for self-regulating, passive denitrification reactors. PHAs offer a potential low-maintenance and cost-effective denitrification method since they act as both carbon sources and substrates for denitrifying bacteria. This, in turn, eliminates the need for the sophisticated control systems and handling of hazardous chemicals required by conventional methods of treatment. 

Fouling solution

Earlier research showed the excellent denitrification capability of PHAs, but excessive biofloc formation from the heterotrophic bacteria using the carbon released from the PHAs fouled the columns and limited the process. 

The authors hypothesized that the problems associated with clogging of the PHA filter bed could be addressed by utilizing AST’s patented PolyGeyser bead filter technology as a denitrification platform. This bead filter promotes a healthy thin biofilm due to its frequent, gentle backwashing, which eliminates the clogging problem observed with packed beds. Additionally, the ability to manipulate backwash frequency allows the biofilm abrasion rate to be tuned. 

Lab study

A lab-scale denitrification system was built with three units that utilized the same design criteria used for the commercial bead filters. Numerous replicated tests were conducted to quantify the denitrification capacity of the PHAs and the impact of backflushing on performance. For each test, water quality samples of influent and effluent were analyzed for pH, ammonia-nitrogen, nitrite-nitrogen, nitrate-nitrogen, and alkalinity. Dissolved oxygen and temperature were also measured in each bioreactor and the production tank. 

In order to characterize the removal rate across the media bed, samples were taken at several depths in the media bed using a syringe with a long stainless steel needle. Samples were taken from below the media, at the bottom, at three locations across the bed, at the top, and finally at the effluent. 

Results

In one such test at a flow rate of 150 ml per minute and with 2 liters of PHA media, the dissolved oxygen levels across the media bed fell quickly from approximately 3.1 mg per liter at the bottom of the media to less than 0.6 mg per liter just above the top. Although the dissolved oxygen content remained above 2.0 mg per liter across 50 percent of the media bed, alkalinity, a byproduct of the denitrification process, increased fairly uniformly across the bed (Fig. 1). The alkalinity increased from 188 to over 240 mg per liter as calcium carbonate, and correspondently, the nitrate-nitrogen levels fell from approximately 100 to 78 mg per liter.

denitrification
Fig. 1: Change in nitrate-nitrogen and alkalinity across the denitrification bioreactor.

The SBIR research showed that removal rates for nitrate by the lab-scale bioreactor units surpassed 2 kg per cubic meter daily with no clogging by biofloc or short circuiting of the media bed. Backwashing to maintain the biofloc was performed every one to two days. Excess biofloc settled quickly to the bottom of the bioreactors and was drained from the system on a daily basis.

(Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in the May/June 2007 print edition of the Global Aquaculture Advocate.)


Now that you've finished reading the article...

… we hope you’ll consider supporting our mission to document the evolution of the global aquaculture industry and share our vast network of contributors’ expansive knowledge every week.

By becoming a Global Aquaculture Alliance member, you’re ensuring that all of the 
pre-competitive work we do through member benefits, resources and events
 (The Academy, The Advocate, GAA Films, GOAL, MyGAA) can continue. An individual membership costs just $50 a year.

Support GAA and Become a Member